Grammar Writing Techniques 2022-09-06 00:00

Analogy vs Metaphor: Understand the Differences

Analogy versus Metaphor

Creating a vivid image in your reader’s mind is a concrete way to create a memorable moment. Metaphors and analogies are literary devices you can use to fix an idea in your reader’s mind. They work differently because a metaphor is a figure of speech but an analogy is a logical argument.

Writer’s Digest Senior Editor Robert Lee Brewer explained:

“A metaphor is something, a simile is like something, and an analogy explains how one thing being like another helps explain them both.”

Let’s look at an example of the difference between a metaphor and an analogy.

Metaphor: Joyce is a pig.

Analogy: Joyce’s personal care and hygiene are the same as a pig who roots in the mud and rolls in the dirt day after day.

The definitions of anologies and metaphors

The goal of the metaphor is to create a mental image in your reader’s mind. The aim of the analogy is to show how two things are alike in order to make a point about the comparison.

With that introduction, let’s look at how metaphors and analogies work in your writing so you can spot the difference.

  1. What Is a Metaphor?
  2. Why Use Metaphors?
  3. What Is an Analogy?
  4. Why Use Analogies?
  5. The Differences Between Metaphors and Analogies

What Is a Metaphor?

A metaphor serves as a figure of speech in writing. A word or phrase is used not literally but as a representation for a vivid effect. In other words, the word or phrase denotes an object to suggest a similarity that is not literal.

Metaphors bring color to your writing using concise words. This combination of economy of words and vivid imagery creates an emotional connection with your reader.

You’ll find metaphors everywhere, from everyday speech to erudite literature.

In Adrian McKinty’s Falling Glass, he describes a view of Hong Kong as “a mashup of Canaletto and Blade Runner.” This metaphor brings to mind a bay filled with boats in Venice combined with the super-modern architecture depicted in the film Blade Runner. It gives the reader an instant visual impression without slowing down the story.

McKinty’s metaphor suggests that Hong Kong looks like a bay filled with boats and a city of almost surreal modern buildings covered in neon. And he does that with just two short references that bring images alive in the reader’s mind.

Why Use Metaphors?

Metaphors create an immediate connection with your reader by generating a visual image. The compressed imagery sparks a response to something familiar while leading to a new way of understanding the compared object.

A practical way to understand metaphors and how you can use them is through metaphor examples. Here are five ways you can use metaphors in your writing.

1. Explain Abstract Concepts in Concrete Terms

Metaphors are useful in fiction because they don’t detract from the storyline but add vivid imagery. A metaphor compresses a concept into an easily understood image.

  • “Memories are bullets. Some whiz by and only spook you. Others tear you open and leave you in pieces.”―Kill the Dead, Richard Kadrey.

  • “If you can look into the seeds of time, and say which grain will grow and which will not, speak then to me.”—Macbeth, William Shakespeare.

2. Create a Sense of Familiarity

Because a metaphor uses familiar imagery, the reader instantly understands the reference.

  • “Mr. Neck storms into class, a bull chasing thirty-three red flags.”—Speak, Laurie Anderson

3. Create An Image in the Reader’s Mind

Because a metaphor condenses down to imagery, the reader “sees” it in their mind.

  • “He could hear Beatty’s voice. ‘Sit down, Montag. Watch. Delicately, like the petals of a flower. Light the first page, light the second page. Each becomes a black butterfly. Beautiful, eh? Light the third page from the second and so on, chainsmoking, chapter by chapter, all the silly things the words mean, all the false promises, all the second-hand notions and time-worn philosophies.’”—Fahrenheit 451, Ray Bradbury.

Ray Bradbury metaphor

4. Trigger Emotions

Because metaphors are concise, you can use them to pack an emotional punch.

  • “The parents looked upon Matilda in particular as nothing more than a scab. A scab is something you have to put up with until the time comes when you can pick it off and flick it away.”—Matilda, Roald Dahl.

5. Illustrate a Character’s Worldview

When a character uses a metaphor, you get a sense of their worldview. Your reader instantly understands how that character sees the world. They understand the character’s personality through the metaphor (image) your character uses.

  • “Bobby Holloway says my imagination is a three-hundred-ring circus. Currently I was in ring two hundred and ninety-nine, with elephants dancing and clowns cart wheeling and tigers leaping through rings of fire. The time had come to step back, leave the main tent, go buy some popcorn and a Coke, bliss out, cool down.”—Seize the Night, Dean Koontz.

  • “You’re television incarnate, Diana. Indifferent to suffering, insensitive to joy.”—Network.

A metaphor is visual shorthand. It plays on the reader’s senses through sounds, images, scents, tastes, images, and touch to make an idea accessible. ProWritingAid’s Sensory Report makes it easy to check that your writing targets all five senses.

ProWritingAid's Sensory Report

What Is an Analogy?

An analogy works by creating a logical argument comparing two things to make a point. Unlike the poetic figure of speech in a metaphor which lets one thing stand for another figuratively, an analogy aims to explain something.

An analogy uses two usually unlike things, and draws a conclusion from the direct comparison. It uses logic to present an argument.

American author E. B. White wrote a memorable example of an analogy:

“Explaining a joke is like dissecting a frog. You understand it better but the frog dies in the process.”

Image of a frog

The analogy presents the argument of how the joke and the frog are similar.

Why Use Analogies?

  • An analogy uses the familiar to help the reader understand the unfamiliar. Using familiar references helps your reader connect with your concept, sharpens their focus on the references, and deepens understanding.

  • An analogy speeds up comprehension of your point. In a few words, you make a logical point rather than leading your reader through a long explanation.

  • Analogies work in fiction to clarify a point so the reader can get on with the story, and in non-fiction to illustrate a difficult point with a concise explanation.

Here are three ways you can use analogies in your writing.

1. Explain Abstract Concepts by Comparing Concrete Terms

While a metaphor creates a visual image, an analogy uses familiar concrete terms and images to solidify a concept. The familiar terms help to illustrate exactly what the writer wants to say.

Analogies work well in fiction to explain a concept without taking a reader away from the storyline. That way the writer avoids long narrative explanations.

Here are some examples of analogies in literature:

  • “Truth, like gold, is to be obtained not by its growth, but by washing away from it all that is not gold.”― Leo Tolstoy.

  • “Joy is to fun what the deep sea is to a puddle. It’s a feeling inside that can hardly be contained.”―A Hat Full of Sky, Terry Pratchett.

  • “If people were like rain, I was like drizzle and she was a hurricane.”―Looking for Alaska, John Green.

2. Create An Image in the Reader’s Mind

References to familiar terms and objects help grab a reader’s attention. Then, the explanation of their relationship works to consolidate the idea. The visual imagery creates a concrete image, often an image with emotional overtones.

The images are a shorthand for understanding the logical concept.

  • “Studying wine taught me that there was a very big difference between soil and dirt: dirt is to soul what zombies are to humans. Soil is full of life, while dirt is devoid of it.”― Into Wine: An Invitation to Pleasure, Olivier Magny.

Olivier Magny Analogy

Here, the writer uses the image of zombies as opposed to humans to emphasize his point. Anyone who has held rich soil in their hand knows how it feels and smells.

And they know how dirt coats the side of their car or dusts their shoes. Without mentioning soil chemistry or physics, the writer evokes the difference and why soil content is important to vineyard culture.

3. Trigger a Logical Conclusion

The best use of an analogy is to lead the reader to a logical conclusion in a visual and concise manner. Non-fiction writers use analogies to introduce and summarize major points.

Speech writers use analogies to help an audience understand their point without a long, tedious explanation. They know that a speech must move in order to maintain audience attention.

Here are some examples from non-fiction and speeches:

  • “You see, wire telegraph is a kind of a very, very long cat. You pull his tail in New York and his head is meowing in Los Angeles. Do you understand this? And radio operates exactly the same way: you send signals here, they receive them there. The only difference is that there is no cat.” ― Albert Einstein.

  • "The Scientist must set in order. Science is built up with facts, as a house is with stones. But a collection of facts is no more a science than a heap of stones is a house.”―Science and Hypothesis, Henri Poincare.

  • “I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at a table of brotherhood.”―Martin Luther King, Jr.

The Differences Between Metaphors and Analogies

While both metaphors and analogies are concise and rely on visual imagery, the intent is different.

An analogy may incorporate metaphors to strengthen imagery in the comparison. The emotional power of metaphors boosts interest in the logical conclusion.

The best way to identify and separate metaphors and analogies is to examine the aim.

Metaphor are for thinking and analogies are for feeling

  • A metaphor uses imagery to evoke an emotion, to feel.
  • An analogy uses comparative imagery to lead to a logical conclusion, to think.
  • A metaphor says a thing is another thing.
  • An analogy compares two divergent terms to draw a reader to a conclusion.

The best way to learn how to tell the difference is to read. Metaphors and analogies are common literary devices—look out for them in the next book you pick up. Your own writing will improve as a result.

Take your writing to the next level:

20 Editing Tips From Professional Writers

20 Editing Tips from Professional Writers

Whether you are writing a novel, essay, article, or email, good writing is an essential part of communicating your ideas.

This guide contains the 20 most important writing tips and techniques from a wide range of professional writers.

Be confident about grammar

Check every email, essay, or story for grammar mistakes. Fix them before you press send.