BlogWriting AppsAutoCrit Not as Good as ProWritingAid

AutoCrit Not as Good as ProWritingAid

The ProWritingAid Team
ProWritingAid: A grammar guru, style editor, and writing mentor in one package.
Published Jan 01, 2012

Updated: December, 2016

ProWritingAid vs. Autocrit

How does ProWritingAid stack up against online editing tool Autocrit? We've carried out direct comparisons below according to a number of criteria.

Contents:
  1. Cost
  2. Free Version
  3. Integrations
  4. Number of Writing Reports
  5. Take Aways

Cost

ProWritingAid Premium

$4.17/month ($50 annually, or less if you purchase a longer license)

Autocrit

$29.97/month ($359.64 annually)

That’s a big difference. But don’t let ProWritingAid’s low cost fool you into thinking it’s not as comprehensive! Keep reading.

Free Version

Both ProWritingAid and Autocrit offer some analysis for free.

Autocrit

Input your text into their free version and you will get an analysis of your adverb usage, including a list of those that you are using too frequently.

ProWritingAid

You get access to every ProWritingAid report, including the Grammar Report, Style Report, Repetition Report, Sticky Sentence Report, Overused Words Report, Sentence Length Report, Readability Report and many more. The free version does, however, have a word count limit, whereas Premium users do not have a limit.

Integrations

Autocrit

Autocrit is an online editing tool and must be used within your internet browser.

ProWritingAid

ProWritingAid Premium users can use ProWritingAid in several ways.

  • The desktop version allows users to open, edit and save a wide variety of files including Scrivener, MS Word, Open Office, RTF, HTML, and markdown. In this way you don’t lose formatting by cutting and pasting into an online tool.

  • We offer add-ins for both MS Word and Google Docs so that you can edit in your favorite platform.

  • You can use ProWritingAid as a Chrome extension so that you can edit on any website, including your posts on Facebook, Twitter, Gmail and more.

Number of Writing Reports

ProWritingAid

ProWritingAid offers the following reports as standard in both the free and paid versions:

Autocrit

Autocrit offers the following reports as part of their paid subscription:

  • Dialogue
  • Strong Writing
  • Word Choice
  • Repetition
  • Compare to Fiction
  • Pacing and Momentum

Take Aways

We think it's pretty clear that ProWritingAid offers a lot more value for money: twice as many writing reports at a fraction of the cost. We haven't even mentioned some of the other free features such as the Word Explorer, Summary Report and Contextual Thesaurus. Just give it a try and see for yourself.

Any other questions? Get in touch at hello@prowritingaid.com

Or click here to take ProWritingAid for a spin now.

Subscribe for writing hacks, special offers and free stuff
We will not share your details
Your Personal Writing Coach

Join over a million writers who already use our editing tool

Try it for free!
ProWritingAid
Have you tried  ProWritingAid  yet? What are you waiting for? It's the best tool for making sure your copy is strong, clear, and error-free!
The ProWritingAid Team
ProWritingAid: A grammar guru, style editor, and writing mentor in one package.

The most successful people in the world have coaches. Whatever your level of writing, ProWritingAid will help you achieve new heights. Exceptional writing depends on much more than just correct grammar. You need an editing tool that also highlights style issues and compares your writing to the best writers in your genre. ProWritingAid helps you find the best way to express your ideas.

And all the reasons above is why I switched.
By Tinapollick on 07 January 2013, 03:53 PM
This article has spelling errors.
By cjpari on 02 June 2014, 08:52 AM
You might want to update this. If the free version doesn't have a word limit, why did I get hit with a 3000 word limit.
By penickjoshua on 24 April 2015, 10:42 PM
I just tried out AutoCrit (the free version). One of the reasons I won't be purchasing it is that in one of its reports, the word "Occurrences" was misspelled as "Occurrances" -- sorry, but if they misspell within their own editing program, I am not impressed. I'll now look at the Pro Writing Aid...
By creative.energy on 03 May 2015, 01:17 AM
I have used both and AutoCrit seems to have some things that are better than Prowriting Aid. It focuses more on wording and flow. I would suggest AutoCrit for a writer who has minimal issues with the basics of grammar and spelling.
By professor1 on 31 July 2016, 10:57 PM
I've looked at both, and autocrit is a great deal easier to use. Your price is right, certainly, but I disagreed with many of the recommendations ProWritingAid gave me. The "sticky sentences" report is almost meaningless, for example. So it's not a great advantage that you offer it. I'm still trying decide if either of these tools will truly be useful to me for the cost (autocrit) or effort (yours) they would take. Of course, editing isn't easy! And it is a boon to have a program that can show you repeated and overused words. So kudos for developing it, even if it proves not to be right for me. Mary
By mekj12 on 17 September 2016, 06:26 PM
I too chose Pro-Writing Aid over Auto-Crit, one reason being price. (Thank you for being so reasonable.) And I'm ever so pleased that you went the extra mile to create a workaround that allowed an integration with Scrivener. Thank you very much for that. But the thing that frustrates me the most is if you don't use the desktop version, and go straight to the web version, you lose your formatting especially as you flip between reports. Am I doing something wrong here? Also, editing within either version can cause some weird spacing problems, and extensive editing, such as rewriting multiple lines exacerbates this. One thing that Auto Crit has seemed to updated is the capacity to set formatting options for export. Perhaps this is something you can look at too. That would be very, very helpful. Thanks!
By bturnage on 19 February 2018, 03:44 PM